eds1275 2011-06-27 - 6:45pm

Here's an example of how things should not be.

3 weeks ago I finished scoring a series of workout videos. Not the most glorious job ever but hey playing music for a living is pretty sweet. The video guy is apparently sooooo good at what he does. He even won a contest once. Whoopdi do. So here is what happened.

I wrote all the music beforehand. The fitness lady made up routines to the beat of the music, and they get all set up to film. After asking my opinion on mics, the video guy decides I have no clue what I'm talking about and proceeds to rent [because he doesn't actually own any] a cheap Apex clip on lapel mic.

Of course it's an omni mic, so he's worried about bleed. So he turns down the cd player they had while filming because he's just going to drop the tracks in after the fact. But they have nothing to work out to. So after day 1, they called me and told me about it and asked me what to do. I gave them like 10 options ranging from keeping the music in and adding it in over top [because it's going to be there anyway], separating the speakers equal distances from the mic and flipping the phase on one side to cencel it out at the mic to wireless headphones to just using directional mics.

Video man tells the fitness trainer that I dunno what I'm doing. Over the next few days, they film the rest of the videos. Without, of course, taking any of my advice. "Don't worry" says Mr. Video - ANY audio guy can sync up the music to video - with ease.

By the time he's edited the videos together and made her a reference copy it becomes clear that he can indeed point a camera at stuff and push the red button - but audio is not his thing. His omni mic in the fitness room has become nearly useless as the extra-reverberant room [hard floors/walls/ceilings/metal workout equipment/giant windows] bounce back into the mic.

He has since given her the video files all edited together with no music added. So the video is there, in HD, all ready to go if it has the audio problems fixed. He's also disappeared, not answering phone calls or emails or anything. I have a feeling he'll show up later to make sure I didn't cut his name out of the credits. I'm about to call the fitness place so that I can get the files delivered to me. I think I can fix the audio without butchering it... but they may be SOL.

Like It!

Replies
‹ Newer

ibzRG 2011-06-28 - 3:22pm

Did you forget your CV and references at home? Because unless you have been lying to us all this time, if anyone knows how to record stuff in complicated conditions it's you.

Not wanting to get into an argument with a cocky tool is noble, but if you are the one who ends up having to clean up the mess and perform some mixing magic, then you should stand up for your qualifications and experience a bit more before the mess is made.

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Kimon-F/97223762538
+0 Votes
eds1275 2011-06-28 - 11:51pm

Ahhh you caught me in my elaborate web of liiiiiieeeeeessssss!!!!

No actually I have never met him. I wrote the music beforehand, then passed it on to the fitness lady. All of this is news to me as of a few days ago. Believe me, I wouldn't take that sort of attitude if I were there "live" on set. And I'm gonna guess he would have kept his mouth shut had I been there.

I got my hands on what is apparently the worst of all the videos - the cardio workout - 45 minutes of starting on the beat and ending at some other point in time. It is really, really distracting when the beat of the music is off when you are trying to work out to it. Not that I got all up in that lady's fitness. But I can imagine. I was trying to count the beats but the flailing legs and arms were throwing me off pretty bad.

I am going to spend the next 2 days trying to get the audio on this flick in sync and then report back on my success! Or I suppose failure - it could happen. I mean, I can surely line up the audio to her movements, but the question is will it sound funny if she speeds up and slows down here and there? Only time will tell.

**Also*** watching the videos, which look very very nice in HD and all that I could see that the cameras were either not the same make and model, or if they were, he didn't set the white balance the same on all 3 cameras. I could tell that, and I'm not even a video guy!!! But other than that the vids are pretty good.

+0 Votes
eds1275 2011-06-29 - 9:14pm

OK I came up with a system that works and is somewhat timely. Here's what I ended up doing.

I imported the video into protools for starters, and then by watching the fitness lady kind of figured out a starting tempo that matched her movements. I then used a software time stretching tool in Protools called Elastic Audio to strech my tune to that beginning tempo. Lined it up with the beginning and watched until she started to fall off the beat. Then I'd go back to just before she fell off and split the audio into 2 files right before a beat, and on a zero-crossing of the waveform. One was the good audio that was in time, the other side was the dark side. Then I'd watch and see if she sped up or slowed down, and squished or stretched the entire rest of the audio file to match. Then watch again until she was again off time. I ended up splicing and dicing every 10-15 seconds or so. It ended up sounding pretty natural actually. It's not like the lady started going berzerk or anything.

The only thing that sucks is that I spend a lot of time and effort putting these tracks together and to cut them up and muck about with the timing seems like blasphemy.

+0 Votes
ibzRG 2011-06-30 - 4:54pm

Yeah, you shouldn't have to micro-manage the beat like that... Umm... did you consider stretching the video instead? >:D

As for you not being there in person, yeah that explains a lot.

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Kimon-F/97223762538
+0 Votes
eds1275 2011-06-30 - 5:27pm

I actually said that. If it's so easy, why don't you just edit the video to make it match lol.

+0 Votes

You must login or register to post to this thread.

Recently Viewed
Login to view your recent items!
Stuff I Liked & Commented On
Login to view your favorites!