Forums > Electric Guitar > what do you recommend for a starter guitar
Jump:
Forums > Electric Guitar > what do you recommend for a starter guitar
Original message:509 days 9 hours 29 minutes ago
0  
Member: guitarman124
1
WebCred
ive been playin guitar for 2 years and now my friend is wanting to start so he asked me what kind of guitar he should get..... i told him i would let him use one of mine but he wants one of his own... so i told him he should get a cheap guitar like a squier or first act to see if he is gonna stick with playin or not.....what kind of guitar do you recommend he should get ..... and do you think he should start out with acoustic or electric
Reply:509 days 9 hours 25 minutes ago
Member: Alex Koepp
    + 1  
232
WebCred
acoustic, that way he'll build up strength in his hands and fingers, makes for an easy transition to electric

and honestly, if you guys have ever seen that Esteban commercial, that is an awesome starter acoustic guitar, best one i have ever played, hell of a value too
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:509 days 9 hours 7 minutes ago
Member: johnny cox
    0  
835
WebCred
Good point Alex. Acoustic is the way to go. I hate it when my new students come in with a new electric. But as far as electrics go I would go with Squier OR Epiphone for starters
My gear recommendations:
  
Plug in, turn up and spank the plank
Reply:509 days 6 hours 16 minutes ago
Member: Richey
    + 1  
1566
WebCred
It depends on how resolved your friend is. If he is the type that quits doing things that are difficult, start him on an electric. It won't hurt his fingers as bad and is easier to play. That way, he won't get discouraged too soon. If he likes to learn the right way and do the hardest things first so that he gets the most return for his time, have him start on acoustic. It depends on the person.
Right now, just try to keep his interest with quick success. Most people never get good because they won't stick with it. When their fingers start hurting and they aren't making a lot of progress, they get discouraged and bored. That seems to be the first hurdle that you have get over. Often times if someone does really well on electric soon after beginning, it may encourage them to continue. They can worry about strengthening their fingers enough to play acoustic later.
I personally think that learning acoustic first is best but, like I said, it depends on the person.
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:507 days 20 hours 48 minutes ago
Member: Daniel Helgason
    + 1  
6
WebCred
A lot of guitar teachers will tell you that most of their students that started on acoustic stuck with it while the ones on electric dropped it after finding it was not as easy as they thought. As to buying a good cheap guitar , set a budget and play ,play , play till you find the one that feels right. For me the search is always fun .
Reply:507 days 20 hours 4 minutes ago
Member: GibsonBoss
    0  
11
WebCred
Its not about having the right guitar for the right price to make someone stick with it,,,,,,,,,,, its all 100% about having the right tutor for the individual,,,,,, i have has some certified registered tutors with all the qualifications and bells and whistles,,,,,,, and with no disrespect to them, they make a living out of it so 100% respect to them,,,,BUT they wernt the right tutors for me ,it became more of a part time job learning the guitar... i have a tutor now who will teach me what i want in the ordr of things i want,,,,it might not be the correct way of doing things but it keeps my drive up and i pick the guitar up and learn what im being taught every minuite u have spare......i play for enjoyment not to get a job in music,,,,, lets be honest there are few people that are actually capable of making it...... for the few that are gifted they need the registered tutors should they want a career in music.

As for the guitar for your friend just play around with different models in the stores. What does he listen to should give u an idea....if he listens to steve vai then u will have a good idea that he will possibly aspire to be a lead guitarist so recommend a guitar with a floyd for all the accrobattics... u know ur friend better than us, u should advise him according to his musical tastes.
I started on a Fender Strat MIA,,,,, way to expensive for a noobie i know,BUT it was the fact that i dropped a shed load of cash on a guitar which made persivere,,,, i wanted to throw the damn thing out of the window at times but it was the fact that the cost kept me at it,,, if i had a cheap old plank i would have thought forget this along time ago....so i never recommend cheap planks.
just my opinion.
gibsonboss.
Reply:506 days 16 hours 50 minutes ago
Member: Richey
    0  
1566
WebCred
I'm with GibsonBoss. My uncle gave me an American Tele for an early graduation present and a Yamaha solid state in the late '80s. I was a BIG Metallica fan at the time. It wasn't until I used my graduation money a year later to buy an ADA MP-1 preamp ($650 in 1990) and a Peavey 412 cab ($450 in 1990) that I really got serious. I decided that I wanted to start a band and like anything that was going to require a capital investment. After purchasing the better equipment, I practiced about 10 hours per day for an entire summer (much to the chagrin of my girlfriend at the time). By the end of the summer, I was good enough to start a band (in my opinion) so that is exactly what I did. The rest is history.
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:507 days 16 hours 44 minutes ago
Member: rockerhippyguy??
    0  
0
WebCred
start him on an acoustic so he gts more into it like the other ppl said. i started on an epiphone les paul jr....pretty good, look cool, and stuff. REALLY cheap.lol.
i recomend an acoustic, but if he wannts to gt an electric MAKE HIM CHOKE HIM too play an acoustic first.
omg.


xD
joaquin carter.
Reply:507 days 16 hours 5 minutes ago
Member: shanejohnson2002
    + 1  
1851
WebCred
I know I'm probably alone in this but my opinion is, if you give a beginner a crappy guitar, you're limiting them from the start. If you have to spend a little more on an instrument that's easy to play and sounds good, then so be it. There's no reason someone should "have" to play on a POS guitar that doesn't stay in tune and has mile-high action just because they're a "noob".

I say if you're going to learn the thing then at least find a decent guitar to start with. Doesn't necessarily have to be expensive. Ibanez has several series in the 2-400 range that are excellent and don't lose a whole lot of resale value. Yamaha Pacifica guitars go for about 1-200 but are WAY underrated. I own 2. Squiers and Epiphones are decent and you can usually find them in pawn shops or on ebay for pretty cheap.

To me the ONLY thing you shouldn't dish out tons of money on right away is an amp. An old fender frontman reverb will do just fine for learning. I tell my students to practice clean most of the time anyway so there's no need for over-the-top tubescreamer-into-a-dual-rectifier distortion. Just a clean channel that works. Once they start getting the hang of it, I *might* tell them to get a distortion pedal and or a delay of their choosing.
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:507 days 16 hours 3 minutes ago
Member: Josh Richards
    0  
1
WebCred
electric because there easier to play and thay don't put that much strain his fingers and I'd recommend a epiphone
My music recommendations:
Reply:507 days 11 hours 43 minutes ago
Member: Daniel Combs
    0  
0
WebCred
Yes, a acoustic wins by far. They will help his fingers as said above. Thats the man reason, and that when he picks up an electric finally he will play way better. He will thank you in the long run.
Reply:507 days 9 hours 7 minutes ago
Member: Def
    0  
20
WebCred
I doesn't matter if he gets acoustic or not. Tell him to get which ever one he wants. For example, when I first started playing, I got an electric because I was really into rock and all that. Now, I play acoustic literally 99% of the time, but I had I initially gotten an acoustic, I probably wouldve gotten bored because I didn't listen to any acoustic music back then.

Anyways, I'd say Squier, Tradition, Epiphone, Yamaha, or whatever has a reputable name and will be half way decent. Stay away from First Act though. Take the style of music he likes into consideration. If he listens to Slayer, perhaps a telecaster won't be such a great choice. If he listens to country, I'd advise against getting a an Ibanez. If he has no idea, getting a Yamaha Pacifica (strat copy, but better than Squier) with a humbucker in the bridge and single coils in the middle and neck position wouldn't be a bad idea. They run for about $150 or so.
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:507 days 8 hours 52 minutes ago
Member: The truth is what we make it....
    + 1  
1
WebCred
I think it depends on what style of music the person is interested in. If they like a lot of acoustic stuff go for an acoustic and pick some easy stuff to play first like some cool chord progressions. If they like rock, blues, pop, jazz, or metal or anything with distortion go for a good Ibanez guitar. They are the best in my opinion for a good all around tone. Plus electric guitars are a lot more flexible and can be played quietly with headphones using a cheap effects processor like the digitech rp series if you dont want to wake everyone up or bother anyone in the next room. I recommend an Ibanez rg350dx. Awsome guitar for the price. Around $350-$400. Hope this helped.
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:506 days 19 hours 38 minutes ago
Member: Grensley
    0  
150
WebCred
may i recommend a compromise. An acoustic with an electric pickup (aren't they all electric?) that way he can build the finger strength and still be able to rock out. Best way to stick with it.
My music recommendations:
My gear recommendations:
  
Reply:506 days 17 hours 31 minutes ago
Member: Daniel George
    0  
0
WebCred
Electric guitar is easier playing, so he may progress more and feel more confident. Acoustic will build up strength also you don't have to worry about the hassle of electric (e.x. effects settings cords, and all that crap) I started electric, been playing 5 yrs. I recommend the Epiphone 150 acoustic for a beginner
Reply:504 days 6 hours 29 minutes ago
Member: Mat Foster
    0  
0
WebCred
Interesting. A lot of people started on acoustic and didn't give it up as quickly as electric. I don't really understand why it makes a difference. The acoustic is "harder" in a way because every mistake can be heard regardless. On the electric, in some cases mistakes can be masked with distortion or other effects. Unless, of course, you aren't plugged in so people can barely hear you unless they want to anyway. In first reading I wanted to state that the best beginner guitar would be like a cheap 100$ strat pack. I had a student's acoustic to begin with but didn't learn until a couple of years later when I got the strat pack. Amazingly, it plays better than my Jackson JR-20 rhoads with 2 emg's(81 and 85). I don't know why either because it was so much cheaper. The Jackson definitely has a better metal sound through my triple rec head but when it comes to blues and jazz I would choose the Fender. So I guess the experience is more or less subjective. Find a guitar that speaks to you :) My 2 cents. Thanks for the reading my guitar brethren!
Reply:503 days 19 hours 16 minutes ago
Member: Johnny
    0